Skip to Main Content

Student Project: Patentability of Genes: Natural DNA compared to cDNA

This research guide will facilitate a legal analysis about whether genes should be patented by providing primary, secondary and other source materials.

Questions Presented

  1. Is natural human DNA patent eligible?
  2. Is complementary DNA (cDNA) patent eligible?

35 U.S.C. 101, Inventions Patentable

"Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title."

In terms of subject matter patentability under 35 U.S.C. 101, DNA is in the category of composition of matter.

Diamond v. Chakrabarty

In Diamond v. Chakrabarty, the Supreme Court held that a genetically engineered bacterium, although a living organism, is a patentable invention because it was altered, and thus made by man.  447 U.S. 303, 309 (1980).  The Court found that Congress intended patentable subject matter to "include anything under the sun that is made by man."  Id.  However, the Court also stated that this broad definition has limits and does not include every discovery; laws of nature, physical phenomena, and abstract ideas are not patentable.  Id.

Synthetic process to make cDNA

Definition of "Complementary" in the DNA synthesis context: DNA is a helical double strand of complementary nucleotide base-pairs.  There are only four different nucleotide bases that comprise DNA.  These are adenine (A), thymine (T), guanine (G) and cytosine (C).  A always chemically pairs with T, and T always pairs with A.  Similarly, G always pairs with C, and C always pairs with G.  This phenomenon is called complementary base-pairing.
Synthesis of complementary DNA (cDNA) is only accomplished in the laboratory (i.e., outside of the body).  (1) The first step is the isolation of natural mRNA from the body.   As described above, mRNA, although derived from DNA, does not contain introns (i.e., non-coding base regions) of DNA because the introns are removed during the natural synthesis of mRNA.  For the purposes of cDNA synthesis in the laboratory, mRNA has an entirely different function than it does in the body.  In the body mRNA  serves as an intermediate in the process of building a protein.  On the other hand, in the laboratory natural mRNA can be used as a template to build a strand of complementary nucleotides to the mRNA template.  (2) The natural mRNA is added to a solution containing a very small string of nucleotides (oligo-dT shown here) known as a primer, which will combine with the mRNA to initiate a double-stranded molecule.  (3) A solution of single nucleotide bases, with all four base types (i.e., A, T, C and G) included, is added to the mixture along with an enzyme called Reverse Transcriptase (RT). This enzyme facilitates the step-wise addition of the individual bases to the chain in a complementary fashion to the bases in the mRNA template.  The result is a double-stranded molecule consisting of the mRNA template combined with a newly synthesized complementary strand.   (4) Another enzyme, RNAse is added to the mixture to degrade the mRNA, leaving only the single strand of DNA complementary to the original mRNA.  (5) Another enzyme, DNA polymerase,  is added to again facilitate complementary base pairing, this time with the newly synthesized, but now single-stranded DNA.  The result is a double-stranded cDNA molecule made up of strands synthesized entirely in the laboratory.  Since cDNA is built entirely from mRNA, which does not contain introns (non-coding base regions), the cDNA necessarily does not contain introns.  Natural DNA, always contains introns, because it replicates in the body from a DNA template, never an mRNA template.  The take-away is that natural DNA always contains introns, and thus is chemically distinct from cDNA, which does not contain introns.  Since the cDNA is a man-made molecule that is chemically distinct from natural DNA, it has been deemed by the US Supreme Court in Myriad to be patent eligible.

Natural form of DNA and its role in the body

In the body natural DNA contains exons (protein coding regions) and introns (non-coding regions).  In the process of making a protein from DNA, the DNA molecule is transcribed into a pre-messenger RNA.  This precursor undergoes an excision of the intron regions by a splicing enzyme.  The resulting messenger RNA (mRNA), devoid of introns, leaves the cell nucleus and enters the cytoplasm.  In the cytoplasm the mRNA will serve as a template, to ultimately build a protein molecule.  Figure obtained from Scitable by Nature Education at\Library.

Schematic Flow Chart for cDNA Synthesis